Baker’s Cay Resort Key Largo Review: The Best Luxury Beachfront Resort for Couples, Families, and Babymoon in Florida
- D Siesta House
- Aug 12
- 8 min read
Updated: Aug 15
Table of Contents
Introduction: Why We Chose Baker’s Cay Resort for Our Key Largo Getaway (Twice!)
If you’re looking for the best resort in Key Largo for couples, families, or business travelers, Baker’s Cay Resort by Hilton should be high on your list. It’s a luxurious yet laid-back waterfront resort that caters to a wide variety of guests. With stunning beaches, serene pools, and a welcoming atmosphere, this resort offers everything from romance to family fun.
This was our second time visiting Baker’s Cay Resort. If you're currently planning your own babymoon, check out our other blog post: The Guide to a Florida Keys Babymoon: Your Relaxing Getaway Before Baby Arrives. We went for our first babymoon in 2023 and returned in 2025 for our second—this time with our two-year-old toddler and me being eight months pregnant. We booked smart using Amex Platinum points, enjoyed perks like a complimentary room upgrade and daily breakfast for two, and left with even more fond memories.
Whether you're planning a romantic escape, a relaxing family vacation, or just want a break from the everyday, Baker’s Cay is one of those rare Florida Keys resorts that truly lets you unwind. There’s no pressure to overschedule your days—just soft sand, calm water, swaying palms, and plenty of shaded hammocks to slow down and breathe. It’s the kind of place where you can sip your morning coffee with an ocean view, let the kids play freely on the beach, or toast the sunset with a mojito in hand. No matter your reason for visiting, if relaxation is what you're after, this spot checks all the boxes.
First Impressions & Arrival Experience
The drive into the resort immediately sets the tone. Palm-lined roads, lush landscaping, and that first glimpse of the turquoise water create an unmistakable island vibe.
Check-in was quick and courteous. The staff welcomed us warmly and let us know we could request a microwave for our room (which we did — a lifesaver for toddler meals). Bell services helped us with our luggage and ensured we had everything we needed.
It’s the kind of place where you can dress up for dinner or just wander around in a swimsuit and sandals and feel right at home.
Room Review: Comfort Meets Caribbean Vibes
Our upgraded room featured a private balcony with a water view, a king bed, and a cozy seating area. The room was spacious and perfect for relaxing between beach visits and naps. Everything was clean, the bed was comfortable, the bathroom was stunning, and housekeeping was responsive. The real standout was the balcony — perfect for sipping coffee in the morning or unwinding after a long day. That said, the furniture could use a refresh. There were some scratches on the floors and the bathroom fixtures looked a bit dated. Nothing major, but worth knowing if you’re expecting five-star luxury.
Beach & Pool Areas: The Heart of Baker’s Cay
Baker’s Cay has two private beaches:
Hammock Beach: Quiet, serene, lined with hammocks and palm trees
Coconut Beach: More active, with paddleboards, kayaks, and games
The water is calm, shallow, and perfect for young kids. Our toddler loved it. We also spent time at the resort family pool. The resort has two pools, which include a family-friendly pool with shallow areas and an adults-only pool for quieter lounging.
Beach cabanas are available to rent, but loungers are first-come, first-served. Arrive early for a prime spot!
🌸 If you’re curious what other travelers think, definitely check out the Baker’s Cay Resort reviews on TripAdvisor—you’ll find tons of helpful tips and honest feedback! 🌸
Dining Experiences: Where We Ate
On-Site Dining
Breakfast at Calusa was included with our Amex booking, and it was wonderful. The tropical open-air setup, ocean view, and variety of options made it one of the highlights of our mornings. The staff — especially one amazing waitress — made our toddler feel like royalty.
Dry Rocks was our dinner spot one night. The food was decent, the drinks were great, and the sunset views were unbeatable. The only downside was the mosquitoes, which were relentless during evening hours.
Off-Property Dining
We also explored a few Key Largo favorites:
Hobo’s Cafe — Our favorite! We went twice. It’s casual, kid-friendly, and delicious. The fresh seafood and relaxed vibe made it an easy win.
Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen (Big) — Great for lunch, with a wide menu and quick service.
Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen (Original) — Smaller and quirkier. Known for their key lime pie and milkshakes.
🌸Please don't just take my word for it, the reviews on TripAdvisor speak for themselves. 🌸
best things to do in key largo
With Friends
For energetic groups seeking excitement, nothing beats exploring Key Largo’s vibrant waters. Top-rated Viator picks include:
Key Largo Two Reef Snorkel Tour – All Snorkel Equipment Included!
The tour visits two coral reef spots like Grecian Rocks and John Pennekamp Park and earns stellar reviews (4.9) Viator.
Tiki Fun Cruise in the Florida Keys, a floating palm-thatched tiki bar experience with music and swimming, is a unique and fun way to hang out (5.0) Viator.
For those craving nature and quiet thrills, I would recommend this tour:
Mangrove Tunnel Kayak Adventure in Key Largo- it navigates through serene mangrove waterways while offering wildlife spotting (4.9) Viator.
With Family
Families looking for easygoing, inclusive activities can enjoy snorkeling at their own pace via the following tours:
Key Largo Snorkeling Tour – rental mask, fins and vest INCLUDED, which caters beautifully to beginners and kids (4.5) Viator.
Half Day Snorkel Trip on Reefs in the Florida Keys - offers a comfortable catamaran journey to the living reef with plenty of swim time for all ages (4.8) Viator.
Mangroves and Manatees – Guided Kayak Eco Tour is another family-friendly half-day choice—guided paddling through mangroves with possible sightings of manatees and dolphins (4.8) Viator.
As a Couple
Couples looking for romantic or intimate experiences have several standouts:
Key Largo Bay Sunset Tour is a private, serene cruise—just the two of you (and maybe local wildlife) as you glide into the sunset (5.0) Viator.
Small Group Florida Keys Eco Tour by Boat offers peaceful wildlife viewing amid lagoons and mangroves—a relaxing shared experience with a personal touch (4.7) Viator.
For something off-the-beaten-path, the Multi-Activity Private Charter Boat in Key Largo can be fully tailored for you—think snorkeling, sandbar lounging, wildlife watching, and romantic sunset views—crafted to your couple’s style (5.0) Viator.
Bonus Highlights Around Key Largo
Not just tours—Key Largo is the “Diving Capital of the World”, home to the John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park, the first undersea park in the U.S., and the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary, offering the only living coral reef in the continental U.S.—ideal for both snorkelers and divers. For a nature-land balance, stroll the Dagny Johnson Key Largo Botanical State Park, spotting native wildlife along its trails, or tour the legendary African Queen steamboat for a nostalgic cruise (you can even take the helm!)
Family-Friendly Amenities That Made a Difference
Baker’s Cay isn’t advertised as a family resort, but it’s incredibly accommodating for parents with young kids:
Microwaves available on request
High chairs and kid-friendly utensils at restaurants
Shallow beaches and splash areas
Spacious grounds for stroller walks
Our toddler had a blast, and we never felt like we were out of place traveling with a young child.
FYI: That fishing toy pictured with my toddler was a total hit, he would even bring it with him at the restaurants. Check out the reviews on amazon.com
Why It’s the best babymoon resort in the florida keys
This resort strikes the perfect tone for romantic getaways and relaxing pre-baby escapes. Whether you're planning your first trip as soon-to-be parents or just craving some one-on-one time before baby arrives, Baker’s Cay offers that peaceful, intimate vibe you’re probably looking for on a babymoon. The resort never feels overly crowded, and the layout makes it easy to find quiet pockets just for the two of you.
There are cozy hammocks tucked between palm trees, soft sandy beaches ideal for lounging with a mocktail, and gorgeous sunset views over the water that instantly slow your pace. I loved how I could just breathe, float, and enjoy—not feeling rushed or overstimulated like I sometimes do at bigger, louder resorts. Everything felt easy and low-pressure.
They also offer spa services, beachfront dining, and plenty of shaded areas so I never felt overheated or uncomfortable even being 8 months pregnant. I especially appreciated the attentive staff who didn’t blink twice at my special requests or toddler-in-tow babymoon setup.
Whether you’re soaking in the views from your private balcony, taking a quiet walk by the water, or just napping in a hammock, it’s the kind of place that gives you the space to rest and connect before life gets busier.
If you’re planning a babymoon in the Florida Keys, Baker’s Cay should absolutely be at the top of your list. I would call it the best babymoon resort in the Forida Keys. It’s easy to get to, easy to enjoy, and full of thoughtful touches that make you feel cared for—without ever being too formal or over-the-top.
Ideal for Business Travelers Too
We noticed a few small business groups and solo travelers. The resort offers:
Quiet spaces for working
Strong Wi-Fi
On-site dining options
Relaxing environment after meetings or work hours
It’s a great mix of productivity and leisure.
Booking Through Amex Travel: Points, Perks & Room Upgrade
We booked our three-night stay through Amex Travel using American Express Platinum points, which came with some serious perks:
Third night free, reducing the average cost significantly
Free daily breakfast for two
Complimentary room upgrade, which we were excited to receive
We were upgraded to a higher-floor room with a beautiful view of the water. The added space and better lighting made a huge difference, especially with a toddler in tow.
If you're wondering how to stay at a luxury resort in Key Largo without paying top dollar, this is the way to do it. Booking through Amex Platinum gave us more value and elevated our experience.
Pros and Cons: Our Honest Thoughts
Pros:
Stunning private beach with calm waters
Room upgrade, free breakfast, and third night free via Amex Travel
Family-friendly without sacrificing luxury
Exceptional service at breakfast
Gorgeous views and tropical landscaping
Cons:
Some furnishings and rooms are a bit dated
Mosquitoes during dinner hours at outdoor restaurants
Limited indoor dining options in the evening
Tips to Maximize Your Stay
Book with Amex Platinum for the best perks
Request a microwave if traveling with kids
Pack bug spray for evening dining
Arrive early to claim shaded beach chairs
Make reservations for Dry Rocks if you want sunset dining
Visit Hobo’s Cafe for the best casual local food
Final Verdict: Would We Return?
Absolutely. This was our second time staying at Baker’s Cay, and we left even more convinced that it’s one of the best places to stay in Key Largo. Whether you’re planning a romantic getaway, a family beach trip, or just want to relax under the palms, this resort delivers.
While there’s room for improvement (hello, mosquitoes), the pros far outweigh the cons. We can’t wait to return — next time, as a family of four.
Have questions about planning your own stay at Baker’s Cay Resort? Drop them in the comments or follow us for more travel tips, family itineraries, and honest reviews.
Happy travels!
Comments